The Act of Killing

"It is forbidden to kill; therefore all murderers are punished unless they kill in large numbers and to the sound of trumpets."
Voltaire

The movies I generally seek out seek are those with a superbly directed cast of gifted actors bringing to life a captivating story. Very rare, however, are those movies that leave you stunned, traumatised even, and unable to articulate anything about the cinematic experience just participated in.

On a recent Monday morning, I was invited to attend a secret screening of The Act Of Killing (Jagal in Indonesian), a film most of us in Indonesia will know of, yet have not been able to watch. Nor will we, except perhaps through illegal downloads once it is on general release everywhere but here in mid-year.

Its subject matter is the genocide of supposed 'communists', members and associates of the Partai Komunis Indonesia (PKI) in 1965/6 in the aftermath of the takeover of Indonesia by Gen. Suharto, and the role played in the killings by 'premen', a word regularly defined in the movie as 'free men'.

It was while filming The Globalization Tapes (2003), a participatory documentary project made with plantation workers in north Sumatra, that directors Joshua Oppenheimer and Christine Cynn "discovered that … one of the military’s main objectives in the killings was to destroy the anti-colonial labour movement that had existed until 1965, and to lure foreign investors with the promise of cheap, docile workers and abundant natural resources."

Killers and survivors continue to live in the same villages: the killers are now the local power structure. By interviewing them and working their way up the heirachy, in 2004 they met Anwar Congo and Adi Zulkadry, leaders of Pasukan Kodok (Frog Squad) in Medan, the most notorious death squad in North Sumatra.

In their youth, the two older men had been cinema ticket scalpers whose silver screen heroes were simplistic and manly: Congo's hero was John Wayne.

The film makers offered the two men, along with Congo's overweight protégé and sidekick Herman Koto who, Congo suggested, could play-act as the Spanish actor Fernando Sancho, the archtypical Mexican heavy in many spaghetti westerns, the opportunity to star in their own film.

l to r. Koto, Congo, Zulkadry

Boastful about their killings, they agreed to re-enact their 'techniques' and certain incidents. Scenes switch between pre-production, the filmed clips, and then the discussion of them by the actor-participants: "No, we did it this way."

And so we have a film within a film.

An early scene sees them visiting areas of Medan trying to recruit locals who'd be prepared to play distraught women whose husbands and sons were being taken away to be tortured and killed before their bodies were dumped in Deli, the city's main river.

In one area, Congo says that they wouldn't find any recruits there because "this is a communist area." Such banality and insouciance is commonplace for much of the film.

Among the print machinery of the Medan Pos, the newspaper publisher, Ibrahim Siruk, says that he'd decided who'd be killed: "My job was to make people hate them – and beat them to a pulp."

This was eagerly done by the Frog Squad. Congo takes the film crew up to the open roof area where he acts out how he would use a length of wire to murder his victims. He explains that knives and bludgeoning had produced too much blood "which left a bad smell."

These aging thugs are well-entrenched within today's power circle and Congo is a hero to many. For example, the then North Sumatra governor Syamsul Arifin glowingly describes how Congo looked after him through his childhood.

(In 2011, Arifin was jailed for six years for corruption, causing state losses of Rp.102 billion (c.$10 million) whilst Langkat regent from 2000 to 2007)

We see Congo fêted at an open air rally by Yapto Soerjosoemarno, the leader of Pemuda Pancasila (PP), the paramilitary organisation with, it claims, three million members. In 65/6, PP ran death squads for the Indonesian army, murdering thousands of alleged communists and Chinese Indonesians across the province of North Sumatra.

Soerjosoemarno, who in 1980 was ‘appointed’ by PP’s death squad leaders, then addresses the troops: “We have too much democracy – it's chaos."

At an indoor rally, PP is addressed by SBY’s then vice-president, Jusuf Kalla. He says, "Premen means 'free men'. We need gangsters to get things done."

Perhaps even more shocking is the arrival at the location of the re-enactment of a raid on a village harbouring 'communists' of the then Deputy Youth Empowerment Minister Sakhyan Asmara, dressed in his PP orange military-style uniform. He advised the amateur actors to show more realism. He left, and they did, leaving several women and children in hysterics, perhaps reliving residual memories from their family histories.

With that support, it is little wonder that Congo and Zulkadry, who at one point is seen wearing a T-shirt with the word 'Apathetic' writ large, demonstrated little remorse.

The final scene, though, may yet prove the true worth of this film.

Congo agrees to play a role as a prisoner about to be garrotted; there are two takes, after which he says, "I can't do that."

He then revisits the upstairs killing zone of the Medan and says, "I knew it was wrong, but I had to do it." He retches once, twice, with his head turned away from the camera, and at the last he is seen standing alone, silent in contemplation.

The version we watched was long, perhaps too long. Yet I couldn't leave until the end when we stood up silently and went our separate ways, traumatised and unable in that moment to articulate what we'd just witnessed cinematically.

As another reviewer has said, "The Act of Killing is a film that is essential and enraging, It begs to be seen, then never watched again."
…………………………………………………………
Websites: http://theactofkilling.com/
http://www.stopimpunity.org/page93.php
…………………………………………………………
First published in the Jakarta Expat magazine 14.1.13

6 Responses to “The Act of Killing”

  1. Harry Nizam says:

    An interesting movie, I hope I can see it.

  2. ultratupai says:

    The Kalla quote sums up the history of Indonesian politics. "We need gangsters to get things done.”
     
    According to Wikipedia: A preman is a member of an Indonesian organized gang, encompassing street level criminals up through crime bosses. Preman are often perceived negatively throughout Indonesian society due to associations with violence and criminality. This root word is derived from a term which describes the "confluence of state power and criminality".
     
    However, organized crime in Indonesian has a more enduring and complicated history, as the confluence of crime syndicates with perceived legitimate political authority has a history extending as far back as the Mataram kingdom. While associated with brigandry and theft, Indonesian crime syndicates have periodically acted as enforcers to maintain authority and order.
     
    The roles of the jago or jawara were particularly important during the Indonesian Revolution, as they often adopted political roles that helped consolidating the power of local authorities.Despite their significance to Indonesian history, syndicates are universally marginalized due to associations with violence and social illegitimacy.
     
    The word jago literally means a rooster and refers to a type of strongman that exists as a part of the everyday life in urban and rural areas of Indonesia. The jago is a social and political actor in both recent and more distant history of Indonesia. In Indonesian popular culture, the jago is often romanticized as a champion of the people whose acts of violence are motivated by a deep sense of justice, honour and order.
     
    The preman is the modern form of the jago. This word originated from the Dutch term vrijman ('free man') which later morphed into preman, referring to a new breed of urban jago who "is not in the service of the Dutch East India Company, but has permission to be in the Indies, and carries out trade for the sake of the VOC. The vrijman, or preman existed in the grey areas where they treaded within the inside and outside of law. Whilst they were admired due to their autonomy, they were also feared by the locals due to their connections to the authorities.

    • Jakartass says:

      Thanks UT.
       
      I had wondered how Kalla could justify saying that, but the lack of modern communications prevented me from doing any research.
       
      Anyway, your contribution demonstrates that plus ça change, c’est toujours la même chose.
       
      Sadly.

  3. ultratupai says:

    Re Kalla: Well, GOLKAR was (is) the ultimate Preman Party.

  4. Jakartass says:

    Read this interview with Joshua Oppenheimer in the Jakarta Post about the aftermath of The Act Of Killing. (He remains in contact with Anwar Kongo … "we care about each other.”)
     
    What is of interest is that Oppenheimer's follow up movie will be from "the perspective of a family of survivors who have to live alongside the perpetrators.”

  5. Jakartass says:

    This is a film about the mass killings produced by an Indonesian for Aljazeera, broadcast in December last year.
     
    "I was one of the first Indonesians, along with a small group of journalists, to attend a secret screening of The Act of Killing in Jakarta. We were told not to reveal the location of the screening for security reasons, which reveals just how sensitive this bloody period in Indonesian history remains today.
     
    "After watching The Act of Killing I felt we should make our own story about the killings. I talked to victims, executioners, witnesses and investigators to find out more about what actually happened. And the more I talked to people, the more gruesome the picture that formed in my head."

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

getting arimidex without doctor arimidex online 1mg arimidex cheap online buy generic arimidex uk i need to order arimidex without a prescription buy cheap generic arimidex online canada pharmacy no prescription buy lamictal in united states online buy cleocin pills in toronto buy next day keflex i need to order lamictal without a prescription fedex keflex without priscription purchase asacol online no membership overnight shipping buy arcoxia doctor prescription no prescription needed feldene buy vantin online cheap buy cleocin pills in toronto cycrin over the counter generic revia vantin with out a prescription cleocin citrate revia 50mg i need to order lamictal without a prescription order benicar overnight cheap Vantin online doctors Arcoxia without rx Buy Cycrin online overnight buy no online rx Tenormin Buy Revia online cheap Buy Zovirax on line without a prescription no rx Desogen Buy Benicar without a prescription buy Feldene from india cheap Casodex no prescription where to purchase generic lamictal online without a rx purchase casodex without prescription buy Revia tablets without prescription Revia without a r x where to purchase cheap Atarax no rx buy vantin without rx from us pharmacy Buy Cleocin next day delivery to buy lamictal order no online rx Cycrin purchace Zovirax online order Arcoxia 120 mg without prescription Arcoxia order overnight shipping cycrin sale Atarax order online Buy Zovirax tablets orlistat express online buy orlistat no prescription low cost buy generic orlistat online no prescription xenical online purchase xenical online consultant order xenical without rx buy online rx xenical without orlistat online consultant orlistat bestellen xenical rx cheap where can i buy orlistat without a perscription? buy orlistat offshore no prescription fedex buy xenical no visa online without prescription order no prescription orlistat non prescription orlistat orlistat cheap no rx required canada were to buy orlistat orlistat overdose orlistat no prescription needed 120mg purchase xenical online without prescription xenical tablets 120 mg no prescription australia how to buy orlistat without a prescription order overnight xenical buy xenical without rx needed purchase generic orlistat online orlistat generic cheapest xenical online canadian generic orlistat no prescription xenical with no r x and free shipping order orlistat without a rx overnight shipping asacol prescription from s online casodex overnight online cheap tenormin for sale online no prescription required non prescription cheap benicar purchase benicar pay pal online without prescription order keflex for cash on delivery where to buy cheap casodex no prescription buy tenormin online no prescription nonprescription zovirax buy cheapest casodexbuy no prior prescription casodex can i get cytotec without a prescription? arcoxia purchased online without prescription principen with free fedex overnight buy herbal revia fedex arcoxia without priscription how to get prescription of lamictal zovirax usa order desogen overnight cheap cycrin mexico canadian zovirax diet pills without a prescription order principen for cash on delivery arcoxia pharmacy buy arcoxia no scams mail order zovirax purchase tenormin online without script casodex online order saturday delivery desogen bestellen desogen in canada cleocin without rx medications buy desogen online overnight where can i purchase zovirax without a prescription buy lamictal online without prescription discount cleocin keflex precio cheap generic benicar buy no perscription atarax buy vantin no rx buy generic cleocin canada tenormin fast delivery no doctors purchase zovirax over the counter cod overnight order prescription free cleocin how to get zovirax zovirax without a rx buy tenormin daily use purchase revia cod overnight delivery can i get principen without a prescription? desogen from mexico generic asacol 400 mg tenormin on line no script how to get zovirax purchase revia online no membership overnight shipping want to buy atarax in malaysia zovirax online without prescription where to buy generic keflex online without a prescription buy vantin overnight tenormin order zovirax with no prescription overnight shipping zovirax shipped overnight without a prescription vantin with no prescriptions buy atarax on line amex buy tenormin generic purchase revia online no membership overnight shipping keflex without rx medications revia effects atarax oral tablet no prescription discount order xenical no visa orlistat online order buy orlistat without a rx overnight delivery buy orlistat shipped cod order xenical no prescription xenical 60 mg without prescription generic xenical online where to purchase orlistat no prescription no fees ordering xenical online without a prescription buy xenical no prescription needed buy orlistat american express buying xenical without a prescription order orlistat order amex xenical prescription online next day delivery cytotec precio order cheap overnight orlistat buy orlistat no prescriptions generic 120mg orlistat online c.o.d xenical el orlistat generico can i get orlistat without rx xenical order overnight low price rx online website orlistat buy xenical next day delivery xenical without a prescription or membership cheap prices on xenical buy generic orlistat online no prescription no prescription xenical generic xenical no prescription xenical non rx fedex overnight free cheap order rx orlistat buy cheap generic orlistat online canada pharmacy no prescription buy orlistat online without prescription from canada orlistat cheap online orlistat from mexico xenical without a r x cheap prices on xenical where can i order xenical online orlistat available at health department indian xenical orlistat online prescription orlistat available canada purchase orlistat free consultation order xenical without a prescription overnight shipping buy orlistat in england xenical with overnight fedex purchase xenical without a rx online purchase orlistat without rx needed orlistat without prescription shipped overnight express buy xenical cheap without prescription order orlistat overnight cheap orlistat available at health department xenical without a prescription overnight shipping orlistat and orlistat xenical without a presciption xenical shipped cash on uk medication orlistat xenical buy online purchasing xenical without a script buy discount orlistat buy generic orlistat canada generic xenical fedex (orlistat no prescription needed 120mg|Orlistat available canada|Orlistat fedex|best place to buy Orlistat online?|buy Orlistat online uk|buy Orlistat no prescription|can i buy Orlistat online|can i get Orlistat without rx|how to order Orlistat|how to purchase Xenical|order Orlistat online no prescription Pharma Life|Pay COD for Xenical without prescription|Orlistat order online|Orlistat ordered without a prescription|Orlistat buy online|were to buy Orlistat) (buy orlistat online without a prescription|Orlistat purchase without perscripotion|buy generic Orlistat online no prescription|buy Orlistat without prescription|buy Orlistat without a prescription in the united states|buy Orlistat 60mg|buy Orlistat next day delivery|Orlistat with no prescription|Orlistat without a prescription|generic Orlistat online|Orlistat 60 mg without a prescription|Orlistat sale no prescription|where to buy Orlistat) (where to buy orlistat by cod|buy Orlistat india|buy generic Orlistat online|buy Orlistat without prescription|buy Orlistat without a prescription in the united states|cheapest online indian pharmacy for Orlistat or generic|pay Orlistat|Xenical online no prescription|Orlistat available at health department|where can i buy Orlistat without a prescription) xenical prescription online next day delivery (orlistat without script|Orlistat online no prescription 120 mg|non prescription Orlistat|ordering Orlistat online without a precription) xenical online cheap (orlistat cheap no rx required canada|Orlistat purchase without perscripotion|buy generic Orlistat online|buy Orlistat pills no prescription|Orlistat precio|Orlistat without a prescription|generic Orlistat online|generic Orlistat without a precsriptions|Orlistat without prescriptions in usa|Xenical generic no prescription) xenical overnight no consult (buy orlistat australia|buy Orlistat|buy Orlistat over the counter|canadian pharmacy no prescription Orlistat|no prescription Orlistat|order Orlistat no prescription|Orlistat no script|where can i buy Orlistat over the counter) no prescriptions needed for xenical buying orlistat online orlistat price real orlistat without prescription orlistat generic buy xenical australia no prescription order orlistat without rx from us pharmacy no prescription orlistat on line pharmacy buy orlistat no visa online without prescription buy orlistat without a prescription online generic orlistat without prescription order orlistat no visa orlistat overnight delivery fed ex buy orlistat cod overnight xenical without a prescription orlistat no perscription required buying xenical without a script no prescription xenical buy orlistat online without prescription how to get xenical without buy xenical order generic xenical online no prescription how to get a xenical prescription buy in orlistat uk overnight no prescription xenical buy orlistat oral xenical from canada buy xenical oral buy orlistat no prescriptions generic orlistat no prescription (buy orlistat canada|generic Orlistat no prescription|Orlistat oral tablet no prescription discount|non prescription Orlistat|ordering Orlistat online without a precription|Orlistat online without a prescription) Orlistat oral tablet no prescription discount where to buy xenical no prescription no fees purchase orlistat paypal without prescription no rx cod orlistat how to order xenical online without a prescription cheap generic xenical no prescription xenical shipped overnight without a prescription orlistat from mexico achat orlistat generic orlistat prices purchase xenical amex online without prescription xenical no doctors prescription orlistat available at health department purchase orlistat paypal without prescription buy maxalt without a perscription where to buy Maxalt by cod buy Maxalt epharmacist buy cleocin without a prescription in the united states Maxalt without prescription Maxalt cheap mexican maxalt prices Maxalt buy cod purchase Maxalt Maxalt buy online buy generic maxalt pills online Maxalt buy buy Maxalt online from canada achat Maxalt how to buy Maxalt without a prescription order Maxalt usa buy Maxalt 5 mg Maxalt from india buy no online rx Rizatriptan buy Maxalt doctor prescription Maxalt no doctors prescription buy low cost Maxalt el Maxalt generico Maxalt pharmacy online Maxalt purchase Maxalt overnight buy Maxalt in india buy discount maxalt online buy Maxalt without a credit card where to buy Maxalt without a prescription Maxalt with repronex online Maxalt purchase buy Maxalt toronto cheap Maxalt uk generic Maxalt online buy cheap generic Maxalt online Maxalt from india is it safe prezzo Maxalt Maxalt 10mg buy Arimidex online uk buy arimidex pharmacy buy Arimidex prescription Arimidex online cheap buy Arimidex store buy Arimidex in australia buy generic Arimidex australia Revia deliver to uk fed ex overnight Keflex no rx foreign clomiphene generic no prescription order Atarax cheap overnight Keflex no prescription to buy buy discount Keflex on line order Tenormin online from mexico cytotec available at health department buy Premarin online usa what is the generic for premarin Premarin buy cheap Premarin online Premarin canada prices cheap Premarin Premarin online order buy Premarin online without prescription order Premarin online no prescription Premarin no prescription needed requip buy online mail order requip where to buy requip online requip generic how to buy requip where can i buy Maxalt without prescription buy pharmacy Maxalt waterview generic atarax without prescription canada asacol online sale without prescription cheap generic tenormin no prescription online ordering zovirax buy discount feldene buy cheap asacol without a prescription purchase vantin visa buy revia online consultation us where to purchase generic revia online without a prescription uk order revia order revia usa cod online revia purchase revia online next day shipping problems with buying revia without rx purchase revia online without prescription order no online rx revia non presciption revia buy revia without a perscription non prescription cheap revia buy Maxalt without doctor buy Maxalt online without prescription Maxalt capsule buy maxalt online us pharmacy Maxalt 10mg purchase Maxalt purchase principen amex online without rx keflex no physician approval buy online cycrin 10 mg buy atarax without prescription order online asacol without prescription best place to buy arcoxia online? buy vantin overnight delivery cycrin shipped c.o.d. where can i buy cycrin without a perscription? purchase cleocin no visa without prescription buy cheap benicar online canadian pharmacy no prescription atarax lamictal ordering without a dr lamictal order overnight shipping cheap cleocin no prescription lamictal online buy saturday delivery buy Maxalt fed ex uk Maxalt buy generic Arimidex canada buy Arimidex uk buy 1 mg Arimidex Arimidex 1 mg without prescription Arimidex in usa buy online Arimidex 1 mg requip prescription online where can i buy Premarin online buy prednisolone online uk requip 1mg what is it used for generic of requip order arcoxia overnight cheap buy benicar on line amex buy feldene toronto cheap zovirax usa desogen without rx is it legal to buy arcoxia online no prescription needed atarax buy revia without a percsription 50 mg lamictal canadian pharmacy no prescription asacol

Bad Behavior has blocked 1708 access attempts in the last 7 days.

-->